The Priesthood of All Queer Believers - The Episcopal Church of the Redeemer

Cincinnati Pride Part 2: Prioritizing Love

In this heartfelt and passionate episode, Anny and Tym wrestle with the question: “What would Jesus do?”—especially in the context of Pride, exclusion, and how different churches interpret scripture and LGBTQ+ inclusion. They reflect on their personal experiences at Pride, contrasting affirming Christian presence with those that condemn. 
They explore how interpretations of scripture—particularly John 3:16–21—are used to justify vastly different theological and social stances. Tym shares regret over his past in exclusionary spaces, and both hosts challenge the weaponization of Christianity against marginalized communities. 
The conversation turns toward definitions of inclusion, critiques of performative allyship, and why exclusion from certain sponsorships or partnerships (like rejecting donations from anti-LGBTQ+ groups) is not hypocrisy, but a stand for integrity and alignment with core values. 
Anny and Tym return repeatedly to the central teaching of Jesus: Love God. Love your neighbor. Love yourself. They name the exhaustion that comes from navigating faith in hostile climates, yet hold on to hope found in small shifts, honest dialogue, and the unwavering truth that God is love—and love must be the priority. 

Cincinnati Pride Part 1: Pride, Privilege, and the Church

In this honest and energetic episode, Anny Stevens-Gleason and Tym House unpack the recent decision by Cincinnati Pride to reject donations from corporations that have rolled back their DEI commitments. They explore the backlash, the importance of community accountability, and what it means to act with integrity—even when it costs something. 
The conversation deepens as they draw parallels between Pride and the Church, asking bold questions about privilege, purpose, and power. What makes Pride different from a July 4th parade? How do we walk alongside queer folks working within unjust systems? And how do we reclaim the word “pride” from harmful theology? 
Filled with storytelling, sass, and spiritual insight, this episode challenges us to imagine a Church—and a world—where justice and joy go hand in hand. 
They end with a prayer for belovedness, courage, and the divine sparkle in all of us. 

The Priesthood of All Queer Believers - Episode 1

Welcome to Priesthood of All Queer Believers, a podcast exploring the intersection of the queer community and the Church—right here in Cincinnati. We’re so glad you’re here!
This is a space for real conversations about faith, identity, and belonging. For too long, the Church has overlooked the sacred truth that queer people are not just guests in God’s house—we are part of the priesthood. We are called, gifted, and essential to the life of the Church. That’s the heart of this podcast. The idea of the priesthood of all believers comes from the belief that every person—regardless of gender, sexuality, or background—is called to participate in God’s work.
Cincinnati has a deep and complex history—one of faith, one of LGBTQ+ activism, and sometimes, one of painful exclusion from religious spaces. But we believe healing is possible. Reconciliation is possible. And it starts with recognizing that the Church needs queer people. Not just as attendees, but as prophets, as pastors, as theologians, as worship leaders, as disciples. We bring something vital to the life of the Church.
In this podcast, we’ll talk with local voices—queer Christians, faith leaders, and community members—who are already living into this calling. We’ll explore what it means to build an inclusive, thriving Church where all people are affirmed in their belovedness and in their ministry. So, if you’ve ever felt like there wasn’t space for you in the Church—like you had to change who you were to belong—this podcast is for you. Because the truth is, you already belong. You are called. You are gifted. And together, we can build a Church where the priesthood of all believers truly includes all believers.
Join us as we dive into various topics affecting the LGBTQ+ Community directly, how those topics intersect the church—and where we go from here. Make sure to subscribe, share, and send us your thoughts—we want this to be a conversation, not just a broadcast. Thanks for being here. And remember, you are already part of God’s work.

Show Intro - The Priesthood of All Queer Believers

Welcome to Priesthood of All Queer Believers, a podcast exploring the intersection of the queer community and the Church—right here in Cincinnati. We’re so glad you’re here!
This is a space for real conversations about faith, identity, and belonging. For too long, the Church has overlooked the sacred truth that queer people are not just guests in God’s house—we are part of the priesthood. We are called, gifted, and essential to the life of the Church. That’s the heart of this podcast. The idea of the priesthood of all believers comes from the belief that every person—regardless of gender, sexuality, or background—is called to participate in God’s work.